Advertisement

Comparison of EPs’ and psychiatrists’ laboratory assessment of psychiatric patients

      Abstract

      EPs frequently transfer psychiatric patients to psychiatric hospitals with the approval and acceptance of a psychiatrist. EPs and psychiatrists have an unknown set of testing routines and requirements that are used to determine medical clearance of the psychiatric patient. The purpose of this study was to compare the routine and required testing performed by EPs as compared with psychiatrists. A survey of routine and required test ordering for the medical clearance of patients presenting with psychiatric complaints by EPs and psychiatrists was developed. The survey contained information on the physician and hospital demographics, tests routinely performed, required tests, and estimated cost of testing. The survey was distributed to all of the 1,055 EPs in Illinois using the American College of Emergency Physicians database and all of the 117 psychiatrists at state-operated psychiatric facilities in the state of Illinois. The surveys were mailed and remailed to the nonresponders in both groups. The results were inputted into an SPSS (Chicago, IL) program to determine frequencies, descriptives, and correlations. The study results comparing the EPs with the psychiatrists were performed using Fisher exact testing. The survey was returned by 507 (48.1%) of the EPs and 65 (56.4%) of the psychiatrists. A total of 37.0% of EPs responded who were mostly 31 to 40 years old (187 of 506), male (347 of 469), and board-certified (348 of 477). The psychiatrists were mostly 51 to 60 years old (36 of 56), male (34 of 57), and board-certified (42 of 59). The most frequent routine and required tests ordered by EPs and psychiatrists were a urine drug screen (routine 378 of 507, 45 of 66 and required 381 of 507, 31 of 66), alcohol (348 of 507, 33 of 66 and 348 of 507, 33 of 66), and complete blood count (270 of 507, 53 of 66 and 334 of 507, 34 of 66) and least frequently electroencephalogram (0 of 507, 2 of 66 and 1 of 507, 0 of 66), computed tomography scan (6 of 507, 3 of 66 and 2 of 507, 0 of 66), and lumbar puncture (1 of 507, 2 of 66 and 0 of 507, 0 of 66) respectively, at a most frequent estimated cost of required testing of $101 to $200 for EPs (102 of 507) and $201 to $300 for psychiatrists (13 of 66). There were 10 of 16 differences in routine test ordering and three of 16 required tests performed by EPs compared with psychiatrists. Although the number of sets required by both groups were different, the tests required by psychiatrists and EPs for medical clearance of the psychiatric patients were found to be similar. It is unknown if the psychiatrists influenced the ordering behavior of the EPs. However, this study does demonstrate a difference in the routine test ordering, implying that these is a difference in the approach to the patient in the ED. Further means to obtain congruence in the testing protocol of psychiatric patients would be a valuable endeavor.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to The American Journal of Emergency Medicine
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Roca R.P
        • Breakey W.R
        • Fisher P.J
        Medical care of psychiatric outpatients.
        Hosp Commun Psych. 1987; 38: 741-745
        • Hall R.C
        • Popkin M.K
        • Devaul R.A
        • Faillace L.A
        • Stickney S.K
        Physical illness presenting as psychiatric disease.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1978; 35: 1315-1320
        • Bunce D.F
        • Jones L.R
        • Badger L.W
        • Jones S.E
        Medical illness in psychiatric patients.
        South Med J. 1982; 75: 941-944
        • Hall R.C
        • Beresford T.P
        • Gardner E.R
        • Popkin M.K
        The medical care of psychiatric patients.
        Hosp Commun Psych. 1982; 3: 25-34
        • Ferguson B
        • Dudleston K
        Detection of physical disorder in newly admitted psychiatric patients.
        Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1986; 74: 485-489
        • Hall R.C
        • Gardner E.R
        • Stickney S.K
        • LeCann A.F
        • Popkin M.K
        Physical illness manifesting as psychiatric disease.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1980; 37: 989-995
        • Osborn H
        Medical clearance of the patient with psychiatric symptoms.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1978; 35: 357-371
        • Koran L
        • Sox H.C
        • Marton K.I
        • et al.
        Medical evaluation of psychiatric patients.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1989; 46: 733-740
        • Koranyi E.K
        Morbidity and rate of undiagnosed physical illnesses in a psychiatric clinic population.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1979; 36: 414-419
        • Hoffman R.S
        Diagnostic errors in the evaluation of behavioral disorders.
        JAMA. 1982; 248: 964-967
        • Summers W.K
        • Munoz R.A
        • Read M.R
        • Marsh G.M
        The psychiatric physical examination—part II.
        J Clin Psychiatry. 1981; 42: 99-102
        • Hall R.C
        • Gardner E.R
        • Popkin M.K
        • Lecann A.F
        • Stickney S.K
        Unrecognized physical illness prompting psychiatric admission.
        Am J Psychiatry. 1981; 138: 629-635
        • Beresford T.P
        • Hall R.C
        • Wilson F.C
        • Blow F.B
        Clinical laboratory data in psychiatric outpatients.
        Psychosomatics. 1985; 26: 731-741
        • Tintinalli J.E
        • Peacock F.W
        • Wright M.A
        Emergency medical evaluation psychiatric patients.
        Ann Emerg Med. 1994; 23: 859-862
        • Elliot R.L
        Patient dumping, COBRA, and the psychiatric hospital.
        Hosp Comm Psych. 1993; 44: 155-158
        • McCourt J.D
        • Weller J.P
        • Broderick K.B
        Mandatory laboratory testing for emergency department (ED) psychiatric medical screening exam (PMSE).
        Acad Emerg Med. 2001; 8 ([Abstract]): 572-573
        • Weissberg M.P
        Emergency room medical clearance.
        Am J Psychiatry. 1979; 136: 787-790
        • Riba M
        • Hale M
        Medical clearance.
        Psychosomatics. 1990; 31: 4
        • McIntyre J.S
        • Romano J
        Is there a stethoscope in the house and is it used?.
        Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1977; 34: 1147-1151
        • Olshaker J.S
        • Browne B
        • Jerrard D.A
        • Prendergast H
        • Stair T.O
        Medical clearance and screening of psychiatric patients in the emergency department.
        Acad Emerg Med. 1997; 4: 124-128
        • Korn C.S
        • Currier G.W
        • Henderson S.O
        Medical clearance of psychiatric patients without medical complaints in the emergency department.
        J Emerg Med. 2000; 18: 173-176
        • Allen M.H
        • Currier G.W
        Medical assessment in the psychiatric service.
        New Directions for Mental Health Services. 1999; 82: 21-28
        • Henneman P.L
        • Mendoza R
        • Lewis R.J
        Prospective evaluation of emergency department medical clearance.
        Ann Emerg Med. 1994; 24: 672-677
        • Zun L.S
        • Leikin J.B
        • Stotland N.L
        • Blade L
        • Marks R.C
        A Tool for the emergency medicine evaluation of psychiatric patients.
        Am J Emerg Med. 1996; 14: 3
      1. Personal communications from Illinois State Mental Hospitals. 2001
        • Moy M.M
        EMTALA and psychiatry.
        The EMTALA Answer Book. Aspen, 2nd Gaithersburg, MD2000